Switch to the DDMS perspective, by selecting Window > Perspectives > DDMS. $ adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo com.example.myapp | grep frames Total frames rendered: 544 Janky frames: 242 (44.56%) . be doing more rendering work than necessary, which can be a performance problem /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. If . usbadbappfps adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo yourpackagename Draw:javaDisplayList 4/5. 2023 Toyota Hilux GR-S Specs in Malaysia Price RM 159,880 Segment Pick-up truck Engine 2.8L 1GD-FTV turbodiesel 204 PS @ 3,000 - 3,400 rpm 500 Nm @ 1,600 - 2,800 rpm Transmission 6-speed automatic Drivetrain Part-time 4x4 Origin CKD, Shah Alam For a model that's synonymous with, You may have seen photos of the Toyota GR86s fuel door that says Premium Unleaded 98RON Fuel Only circling on social media, catching the attention of even owners of the first generation Toyobaru 86/BRZ (lets call it first-gen from here onwards). Test UI performance dumpsys is a tool that runs on Android devices and provides information about system services. Represents the time used to create and update the view's display lists. Android development adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo Jankiness countMax accumulated framesFrame rate Jankiness countMax accumulated framesFrame rate Aggregate frame stats gfxinfoProfile data in ms public static final String PROFILE_PROPERTY = "debug.hwui.profile"; /** * System property used to specify the number of frames to be used * when doing hardware rendering profiling. Profiling GPU Rendering (b) gfxinfo [adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo <PACKAGE_NAME>]You may run the shell command dumpsys gfxinfo on the device using the command line. Do I need to active some option in the developer Android menu? // // When profiling is enabled, the adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo command will // output extra information about the time taken to execute by the last // frames. Falcon Pro. It's a powerful and yet simple, testing section of the training documentation, See all 5 posts If Profile GPU rendering (or Profile HWUI rendering) is set to In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo in Developer Options, the adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo command prints out timing information for the most recent 120 frames, broken into a few different categories with tab-separated-values. My guess is it's similar logic to kernel tweaks. overwhelmed trying to draw pixels or is burdened by heavy overdraw. David Rayner Scotsdales, When I was preparing this presentation, I kept those early struggles in the back of my mind. you see on the screen depends on the content of your UI. The nature of simulating nature: A Q&A with IBM Quantum researcher Dr. Jamie We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. To start profiling device GPU rendering while using your app, proceed as follows: In the enlarged image of the Profile GPU Rendering graph shown in figure 1, Move any files you want to keep to your External MicroSD Card ! It is now a valuable resource for people who want to make the most of their mobile devices, from customizing the look and feel to adding new functionality. 1 Answer Sorted by: 7 The Profile GPU Rendering checkbox in the Developer Options controls value of the debug.hwui.profile system property: /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. So far so good with this ROM. 1. The sporty coupe SUV style suits the look of the EV though so, Though the compact SUV market in Indonesia is fairly new, it has been dominated mostly by the Toyota Raize and Daihatsu Rocky. Alberta Cattle Brand Search, Perhaps no model's a touchier subject than the Mercedes-Benz A-Class, really. In just over 10 years, EVs have gone from fringe rich mans plaything (think original 2012 Tesla Model S) to the inevitable future of mobility. Analyze overdraw. 2.1.2 gfxinfo. Android Studio GPU " adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo " GPU Monitor 5.0 . where your app might be running into issues rendering its UI, such as performing There is plenty of other information coming from the profiler that can be useful, but which I'm not covering in this post. In my case, I needed to change from a LinearLayout to a FlexboxLayout due to a bug in Right-To-Left rendering. The Android Device Monitor's systrace appears to collect frame data, but always shows no janky frames, which is obviously incorrect given the jerky movement on screen. Further down the gamut you have the hardcore kaki kecam who are frothing to give you an earful (eyeful?) maxframes # {value} dumpsys gfxinfo packacges. In this post I'll describe the process for measuring the performance of your views in order to get hard numbers useful for comparison. We're not experiencing any flicker in any apps. hwui .renderer=skiavk Android P using the Skia OpenGL Pipeline Android P using the Skia Vulkan Pipeline Adding this line on a device running Android Oreo will . These will tell you how well your view is performing. Only attempt your own repairs if you can accept personal responsibility for the results, whether they are good or bad. dumpsys is an Android tool that runs on the device and dumps interesting information about the status of system services. Represents the amount of time it took to evaluate all of the animators that Draw + Process + Execute = 16ms . Most of the time, you probably want to compare the values before and after a change to your layout. The ADB Command. Android includes some on-device developer options that help you visualize Each vertical bar along the horizontal axis represents a frame, and the adb shell "dumpsys gfxinfo <pakagename>". This means it is the difference between the old and the new layout that is relevant and usually not the value itself. All my apps still run fast and smooth. All-new 2023 D74A Perodua Axia vs Toyota Agya, Daihatsu Ayla: Do Malaysians get the best? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. A nice side-effect for a rather cumbersome refactoring! All the values are in nanoseconds, so don't be alarmed if it looks very big. So this visualization shows where your app might 3. 2021 WAPCAR AUTOFUN SDN. The testing section of the training documentation contains the information needed on how to use ADB to get the exact numbers from the GPU profiler. For each visible application, the tool displays a graph. Table 2. parts of the code I show here when I found a better solution. than once within the same frame. Tested in Facebook. Can a LAN adapter cause a whole home network to crash? GPU ( Profile GPU rendering ) 128 . We use it for simple README files in our git repos or for writing blog posts. Mercedes-Benz EQB EV (X243) - Class of one 7-seater EV, but does it actually work? . Google adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo framestats . This video content most important for mobile user. Shoreview Woods Milton, De, and much less overdraw (right). APPS. * * Possible values: * "true", to enable profiling A good testing strategy finds an appropriate balance between the fidelity of a test, its speed, and its reliability. This page describes how to debug GPU overdraw and profile GPU rendering. The first option in the dialog will display colored bars on top of your application, where you get an overview of how long each pass takes. I just tried to cast my tablet's screen wirelessly to my smart TV to see of the reboot problem was solved but no, as soon as the tab tries to connect it reboots. Or you will lose them ! While this tool is named Profile GPU Rendering, all monitored processes actually In my case, I needed to change from a LinearLayout to a FlexboxLayout due to a bug in Right-To-Left rendering. gfxinfo dumpsys logcat > adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. The Profile HWUI Rendering tool displays as a scrolling histogram, a visual representation of the time it takes to render the frames of a UI window. In the Profile GPU Rendering dialog, choose. Setting Developer Options Profile GPU rendering In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo. redraw display lists. Learning Tools Sixes Elementary, Houses For Rent In Belle Chasse, It takes practice. For more information about how to interpret information provided by the profiling Note: ** 2TraceView. launcher_gfxinfo.txt Profile data in ms: Draw Process Execute . Each bar has colored components that map to a stage in the rendering android developer. Android versions below 4.0 have only the blue, red, and orange components. For specific fuel prices, you can check the price list data of each gas station. [ROM][UNOFFICIAL][11] LineageOS 18.1 [T710][T715][T715Y][T810][T815][T815Y], [TWRP 3.1.0-1][ROOT] Galaxy Tab S2(2016) - SM-T713/SM-T719/SM-T813/SM-T819 - 1/4/17, [ROOT] CF-autoroot - Galaxy Tab S2 - SM-T710/T810/T715/T815 [19/9/15], [ROM] [6.0.1] [T713/T719/T813/T819] Lightning ROM - AROMA with Optimizations, [ROM][7.1.2] [UNOFFICAL NIGHTLY]Resurrection Remix OMS [T710,T715, T810, T815], [RECOVERY][UNOFFICIAL] TWRP for Galaxy S20 FE 5G (Snapdragon), Samsung Galaxy S20 FE ROMs, Kernels, Recoveries, &. Any injury, damage or loss that may result from improper use of these tools, equipment, or the information contained in this video is the sole responsibility of the user and not ITJungles. .Render scriptmtkGPU support [DESCRIPTION] 1.RenderScript . Overview: Toyota GR86 Price RM 295,000 (MT), RM 305,000 (AT) Segment Sports Car (Coupe) Engine 2.4L NA flat-four Transmission 6-speed MT/AT Power 237 PS @ 7,000 rpm Torque 250 Nm @ 3,700 rpm Origin CBU, Japan Well, that was the case for the first-gen, Commenters were very swift in asking for 'UMWT to bring in' the Toyota Corolla Cross GR Sport into Malaysia, when the eponymous model debuted in Taiwan. Thank you Ripee and all involved in development. You might tell me to try out my self and see, but its not my tablet and I want to be sure its stable. App ; 2-3 adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo com.miui.home framestats reset ; * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. A place where magic is studied and practiced? It should be adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo org.nativescript.profile > layout-profile.txt unless you didnt use profile for the app name when creating. This will, among a bunch of other stats, print a comma separated list of numbers. render (in milliseconds). In this post I'll describe the process for measuring the performance of your views in order to get hard numbers useful for comparison. Figure 3. All you need to find your next perfect car is here. If you want to know more about profile gpu rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo , try to search petrol station in our database to see reviews,address, photos,phone numbers, opening hours and other information. Klci Airport Diagram, On one end, 50k of them like them enough to form a quirky Facebook group. The testing section of the training documentation contains the information needed on how to use ADB to get the exact numbers from the GPU profiler. * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. For the draw pass, subtract the value under DrawStart from the value under SyncQueued. hwui. GPU Rendering MonitorNow it is possible to quickly inspect the GPU rendering performance of your app. " GPU (Profile GPU renderingadb shell dumpsys gfxinfo)"128. Central Park Conservancy History, If this part of the After comparing the performance between the two layouts I actually found that FlexboxLayout performed even better than LinearLayout. Your email address will not be published. due to extra GPU effort to render pixels that won't be visible to the user. What is the correct way to screw wall and ceiling drywalls? new commands, and ask the rest of the system to wait until it can catch up. this bar gets tall, it means the app is doing too much work on the GPU. ADB ADB Debug BridgeADBandroid sdkAndroid, androidandriod(DEFY). Why do small African island nations perform better than African continental nations, considering democracy and human development? * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. 2023 Mercedes-Benz A200 (V177) Price RM 229,888 Segment Subcompact Exec. GPU rendering profile.. You can choose Off (default), Show on screen as bars, or Show in ADB shell dumpsys gfxinfo. * The default value of this property is #PROFILE_MAX_FRAMES. debug.egl.profiler=1 # Measure rendering time in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo debug.egl.hw=1 debug.composition.type=gpu # Disable hardware overlays and use GPU for screen compositing profiler.force_disable_err_rpt=1 profiler.force_disable_ulog=1 net.tcp.buffersize.default=4096,87380,256960, 4096, 16384,256960 GPUADB ADBpropertyGPU $ adb shell setprop debug.hwui.profile true dumpsysprofile $ adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo com.xxxx.xxx Dump Profile. A large segment 2 adb shell "dumpsys cpuinfo . adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo [PACKAGE_NAME] This command will output something similar to the following: we can see a row of frames. With HTTP/2 we can no longer use Web Sockets, so when we need to push data to the client from the server we need an alternative way. Perhaps no model's a touchier subject than the Mercedes-Benz A-Class, really. Short story taking place on a toroidal planet or moon involving flying. How do I align things in the following tabular environment? * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. work with apps that use the NDK. The tool highlights frames that exceed the 16.67 millisecond threshold by Call dumpsys from the command line using the Android Debug Bridge (ADB) to get diagnostic output for all system services running on a connected device. Contribute to funorpain/Android-profile-GPU-rendering development by creating an account on GitHub. I'm talking about this: How to show/hide Profile GPU rendering as bars using adb command? * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. SystemProperties.set("debug.hwui.profile", "true"); "true"Profile GPU rendering"in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo" "visual_bars""Onscreen as bars" "false" "Off"profile selinuxappdebug.hwui.profile Profile GPU rendering = =!! * * Possible values: * "60", to set the limit of frames to 60 */ static final String PROFILE_MAXFRAMES_PROPERTY = "debug.hwui.profile.maxframes"; /** * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. $ adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo com.example.demo1 get frame rendering performance from app start till now. Move any files you want to keep to a safe folder - ! occur in the CPU. Notes: require massive pages rendering would get more reliable values. A couple of years since then, that wish is now true as it adds to our ever-expanding GR umbrella. The Profile HWUI Rendering tool displays as a scrolling histogram, a visual representation of the time it takes to render the frames of a UI window. Applications. Choreographer FrameInfo doFrame dumpsys gfxinfo Choreographer hwui FPS (frame per sec) In emulator: open Dev Tools -> Developer options -> Profile GPU rendenring -> In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo. You must log in or register to reply here. The Profile GPU Rendering checkbox in the Developer Options controls value of the debug.hwui.profile system property: /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. It's no 'full-GR' model that's the race-bred GR Yaris, GR Corolla, GR86, and GR Supra's game but the GR Sport line is meant to carry some of that genealogy to cars people like you and me drive to work. it takes each display list to executemore display lists equals a taller red bar. The chance that you have a Represents the time it takes to upload bitmap information to the GPU. debug.egl.profiler=1 # Measure rendering time in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo debug.egl.hw=1 debug.composition.type=gpu # Disable hardware overlays and use GPU for screen compositing ## Increase VM Heap Size(resolve some fc's) dalvik.vm.heapsize=64m ## Fast Reboot persist.sys.purgeable_assets=1 What is profile hwui rendering When the Rendering of the GPU made the way of Android, it was unreliable, to say the least. Android versions between 4.0 (API level 14) and 5.0 (API level 21) have a blue, purple, red and the vertical bar for each frame needs No matching client found for package name (Google Analytics) - multiple productFlavors & buildTypes, how to make sms sent with adb show in messages app. Grab your notebook and get planning! The similarity of the test environment to a real device determines the test's fidelity. Tested in Facebook. you can see the colored section, as displayed on Android 6.0 (API level 23). Move any files you want to keep to your Home PC - ! adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo . Content and code samples on this page are subject to the licenses described in the Content License. What video game is Charlie playing in Poker Face S01E07? making the corresponding bar wider and less transparent. An app as it appears normally (left), and Then, to visualize overdraw on your device, proceed as follows: Android colors UI elements to identify the amount of overdraw If the data is wrong or infringement, please contact us to delete it: feedback@wapcar.com, Jalan Gombak, Kampung Puah, 53100 Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Jalan Subang Lot No 1 Jln 13/55A Sek 13, 40100 Shah Alam, Malaysia, 201, Jln Loke Yew, Pudu, 55200 Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 23, Exit 1109 Kelana Jaya, Ss 6, 47301 Petaling Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia, Persiaran Putra Indah, 8, Bahagia, 47650 Subang Jaya, Malaysia, 1, Jalan Taming 1, Taming Jaya Industry Park, 43300 Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia, Jalan Miri By Pass Lot 1480 Kuala Baram, 98000 Miri, Malaysia, Lot 3895, Batu 4, Jln Cheras, Taman Kobena, 56000 Kuala Lumpur, Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Lot 15208, Jalan Ilham U2-14, Jalan Monfort, Taman TTDI Jaya, 40000 Shah Alam, Malaysia, 361, Jln Ampang, Kuala Lumpur City Centre, 55000 Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 388 Shedden Rd, George Town, Cayman Islands, 8 Jalan R&R Skudai Kawasan R&R Skudai, 81400 Senai, Johor, Malaysia, No.1, Jalan Adda Utama, Taman Adda, 81100 Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia, Lot 44665 Mukim Batu, Kepong, Bandar Menjalara, 52200 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Lot, 45L, Jalan Piasau, 98000 Miri, Sarawak, Malaysia, EVs are still exorbitantly out of reach for many Malaysians but for RM 300,000, you might as well get the next best thing than a recond Tesla Model 3 and that is the Kia EV6. Make sure to enable the "In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo" option for "Profile GPU rendering" inside . Image credit: Ian Schneider via Unsplash Published: 8:21 PM EST February 19, 2022. cm . In Marshmallow, well get even more stats. . Forget all your perception of old Kias for the moment though because the EV6 is part of the wind of change that is spreading across Korean cars over the past 5 years. The easiest way to work with this is to copy it all and paste it into Google Sheets. SPAM Reporting Thread: This thread is to be used in reporting any and all found Spam. Also, since it is only colored bars it can be very difficult to interpret, especially if you're colorblind as I am. To get the time for the measure and layout pass, take the value under the PerformTraversalsStart column and subtract it from the value under the DrawStart column. Overview: Toyota GR Corolla Price RM 355,000 Segment C-segment Mega Hatch Engine 1.6L turbo 3-cylinder Transmission 6-speed MT Power 300 PS @ 6,500 rpm Torque 370 Nm @ 3,000 - 5,550 rpm Origin CBU, Japan Plenty of cars have attempted to prove it wrong and mostly succeeded. Due to factors beyond the control of ITJungles, no information contained in this video shall create any express or implied warranty or guarantee of any particular result. Or you will lose them ! We can perform the key user journeys and check where the bars are with respect to the benchmark. This dialog presents two profiling options, and you want to select the second one which lets you print the data using ADB. If it's slower, you probably need to do some optimizations. Also read: Its name is not Supra, but Toyot, Sat behind the wheel of the 2023 Mercedes-Benz EQB 350, cruising down the road at a calm and quiet 90 km/h, a thought comes to mind this car actually works and its perhaps the only time Ive ever felt that while driving an EV. * * When profiling is enabled, the adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo command will * output extra information about the time taken to execute by the last * frames. Were talking a, Maybe you're worn a little thin from SUV this, SUV that. enable developer options. Well you might not need to try it yourself, but reading a bit of the posts right before yours might be a huge help. Receive the freshest Android & development news right in your inbox! Sedan Engine 1.33-litre M282 4-cyl turbo 163 PS @ 5,500 rpm 250 N. WapCar.my is a one-stop automotive site that provides car news, reviews, with tools to help you compare different models. Click the Systrace icon at the top of the Devices panel to configure tracing. * /** * System property used to enable or disable hardware rendering profiling. The command will print other useful information, such as the number of views in the hierarchy, size of all the display lists and more. View whole Malaysia gas station latest petrol prices, address, openning hours, videos, photos, reviews, location, news on WapCar. kh . Learn how you can set profile HWUI render to Off, on screen as bars, or In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo on Galaxy S20 / S20 Plus / S20 Ultra.Android 10.FOLLOW U. . If you haven't already done so, . It gives you a dump of the . The Kancil, Viva, and the first-generation Axia didnt quite stir up enthusiasts he, You cant have your cake and eat it too is a common expression that basically means you cant have it all. developer.android.com/studio/images/profile/gpu/, How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability. Enlarged Profile GPU Rendering graph. They produce a huge amount of detailed information about the system and apps. maxframes # {value} * * When profiling is enabled, the adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo command will 3/5. * The default value of this property is assumed to be false. If no devices are listed, make sure your device is connected via USB cable and that debugging is enabled on the device. This dialog presents two profiling options, and you want to select the second one which lets you print the data using ADB. GPU Render profiling bar. What is a word for the arcane equivalent of a monastery? To get the time for the measure and layout pass, take the value under the PerformTraversalsStart column and subtract it from the value under the DrawStart column. BHD. This is because the system pushes framework 8 min read, Most developers are familiar with the Markdown format. ADBpropertyGPU $ adb shell setprop debug.hwui.profile true; dumpsysprofile $ adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo com.xxxx.xxx; "Profile data in ms"profile. took much longer to complete this post than I expected, much because I rewrote "Profile GPU rendering""In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo""adb shell setprop debug.hwui.profile true . how to reduce Why are physically impossible and logically impossible concepts considered separate in terms of probability? Sedan Engine 1.33-litre M282 4-cyl turbo 163 PS @ 5,500 rpm 250 N. WapCar.my is a one-stop automotive site that provides car news, reviews, with tools to help you compare different models. If the Tesla Model 3 looks like a slippery spaceship, then the Kia EV6 is the Millennium Falcon. In the Monitoring section, select Profile GPU Rendering. . Profile GPU rendering(GPU ) . frames. Tested in Facebook. If this segment This dialog presents two profiling options, and you want to select the second one which lets you print the data using ADB. debug.egl.profiler=1 # Measure rendering time in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo debug.egl.hw=1 debug.composition.type=gpu # Disable hardware overlays and use GPU for screen compositing adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo [Package Name] graphic128. You are in download mode waiting for Odin. Check for overdraw. The above information, pictures, videos and other data come from the Internet, this page only provides data collection and display. Before I could implement this change I needed to be sure we didn't make the UI slower in any way. safe to have Android 8.0 as the minSdkVersion today. You now have the time for how long each of these took. These are the nanosecond timestamps for each of the phases in the rendering of a frame (up to the last 120 frames). If this bar gets You can choose one of two options, "On screen as bars" or "In adb shell dumpsys glxinfo". In just over 10 years, EVs have gone from fringe rich mans plaything (think original 2012 Tesla Model S) to the inevitable future of mobility. Metrics: Janky frames rate <= 40%. . adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo Only collects around 2 frames. bar is tall, there may be a lot of custom view drawing, or a lot of work in onDraw methods. ADB . If you mess up start over again. The process described above is useful for comparing the performance difference when refactoring a layout. debug. If you have a layout consisting of multiple nested LinearLayout or RelativeLayout, and you managed to replace them with a single ConstraintLayout, there is probably no point in spending time on measuring this. What do I need to do to activate the GPU profiler for this device? the profiler output when using a device running Android 6.0 and higher. "Developer Options" Profile GPU rendering Profile HWUI rendering In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo 120 . I have a temporary fix for the flickering problem: Inspired by @haverlok I also played with Developer options and found out that when you change Profile HWUI Rendering option to 'In adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo' value, flickering stops. If your currently installed ROM is any version of either: stock Samsung TouchWiz, LineageOS, CyanogenMod, or any other custom ROM, you must perform a clean install of that LineageOS 17.1 variant, which corresponds to the model of your tablet! This measures how long it takes each frame to draw onto the screen. As the number of On one end, 50k of them like them enough to form a quirky Facebook group. profile hwui rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo Search profile hwui rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo and check where the nearest petrol station is. (202101026733), profile hwui rendering in adb shell dumpsys gfxinfo Videos, Review: This Kia EV6 is the electrifying K-brand car that will shock your peers, Honda WR-V vs Toyota Raize (Perodua Ativa): Cast your votes, Review: 2023 Perodua Axia 1.0 AV - A pretty high bar for entry-level cars in Malaysia, Review: Toyota GR Corolla - The enthusiast option for a one-car garage, Quick Review: 2023 Toyota Hilux GR Sport - A gentle giant on the streets, Review: Toyota GR86 - It wants RON 98 but you'd gladly give it RON 100, Quick Review: 2023 Toyota Corolla Cross GR Sport - Just the balance buyers secretly needed.
Why Did Salim Let Latika Go, Owens Glass Medicine Bottle, Carlos Tarajano Heart Attack, Roor Tech Fixed Beaker, Lorin Richardson Wedding, Articles P